Jeffrey Johnson is a legal writer with a focus on personal injury. He has worked on personal injury and sovereign immunity litigation in addition to experience in family, estate, and criminal law. He earned a J.D. from the University of Baltimore and has worked in legal offices and non-profits in Maryland, Texas, and North Carolina. He has also earned an MFA in screenwriting from Chapman Univer...

Full Bio →

Written by Jeffrey Johnson
Insurance Lawyer Jeffrey Johnson

Laura Walker graduated college with a BS in Criminal Justice with a minor in Political Science. She married her husband and began working in the family insurance business in 2005. She became a licensed agent and wrote P&C business focusing on personal lines insurance. Laura serviced existing business and wrote new business. She now uses her insurance background to help educate drivers about...

Full Bio →

Reviewed by Laura Walker
Licensed Agent for 10 Years Laura Walker

UPDATED: Apr 25, 2022

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident auto insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one auto insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about auto insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything auto insurance-related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by auto insurance experts.

Allstate and Liberty Mutual are 2 of the largest car insurance companies in America with a combined market share of over 15% but who is the better insurance provider?

Car insurance companies of this size surely have reasons why drivers continue to sign up but its important to compare auto insurance providers on much more than the cost of premiums.

Both Allstate and Liberty Mutual offer a wide range of policy coverage, additional types of insurance and discounts.

Use our FREE quote tool to compare auto insurance rates today!

About Allstate Insurance

Allstate controls approximately 11% of the automobile insurance market in the United States. Founded in 1931, the idea for the company was born during a game of bridge in 1930. Insurance broker Carl Odell pitched selling car insurance by direct mail to Robert Wood, the president and CEO of Sears.

Odell thought that selling insurance directly would eliminate the costs of hiring salesmen. Wood liked the idea, and so did the board of directors.

The Allstate Insurance Company was founded the following year, selling insurance by direct mail and through the Sears catalog. The company took in over $100,000 in premiums that year, and by 1933 it was showing a profit of $93,000.

Read a Full Allstate Car Insurance Review

About Liberty Mutual Insurance

Liberty Mutual was founded in 1912 as the Massachusetts Employees Insurance Association. The MEIA was founded in response to the growth of workers’ compensation laws. The company’s name was changed to Liberty Mutual in 1917. Over those five years, the focus of the company changed.

Seeking diversification but limited by law to liability insurance, the MEIA partnered with the United Mutual Fire Insurance Company, which would later become one of the founding members of the Liberty Mutual Holding Group.

In 1915 the Massachusetts state legislature passed laws enabling the company to expand to other forms of insurance like automobile insurance. Growth was rapid and by 1937 the company was operating in 48 states.

Read a Full Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Review

Allstate Auto Insurance Offerings

The Allstate Insurance Company offers a wide range of car insurance coverage including all the typical types of coverage such as liability, comprehensive, collision, GAP insurance and more.

How many car insurance companies differ is not by the type of coverage offered but the number of car insurance discounts, customer satisfaction levels, claims handling process, account management options and more.

Allstate excels in offering car insurance discounts and has even introduced Single Accident Forgiveness, which prevents rates from rising after a single accident, even if you are at fault.

In addition, Allstate will reduce the collision deductible by $100.00 the day you sign up. Every year that passes without an accident, the deductible will be reduced by an additional $100.00 up to a limit of $500.00. For every six months that elapse without an accident, you are eligible to receive a check for up to 5% of your premium.

Finally, if your car is totaled within the first three model years, Allstate will replace the car. Whether or not you qualify for all these additional benefits will depend on your profile but for most good drivers Allstate is one of the best providers around.

Liberty Mutual Product Offerings

Liberty Mutual has a number of unique features attached to their auto insurance offerings including guaranteed rates for up to twelve months after the policy is purchased. If you have both home and auto coverage, you can take advantage of a multi-policy discounts that can save up to 10% off your home insurance premiums.

Liberty Mutual also offers a lifetime guarantee for car repairs done through any of their approved facilities.

Rental vehicles are guaranteed if rental coverage is purchased with the regular policy. Premiums will not be raised after an accident if there are no accidents in the previous five years, and no driving violations in the previous three years.

Vehicles which suffer total loss also are guaranteed coverage for a vehicle one model year newer.

Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance Benefits vary by state and all drivers may not qualify for them but overall the company has many advantages over smaller car insurance companies.

FREE Auto Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top auto insurance companies and save!

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Allstate vs. Liberty Mutual Industry Ratings

According to the 2010 National Auto Insurance Study published by J.D. Powers & Associates, the customer rankings for Allstate and Liberty Mutual using a scale of 1 to 5 (with 5 being the highest) are as follows:

  • Overall Satisfaction: Allstate 3/5  –  Liberty Mutual 3/5
  • Contacting the Insurer: Allstate 3/5  –  Liberty Mutual 3/5
  • Policy Offerings: Allstate 3/5  –  Liberty Mutual 3/5
  • Billing and Payment: Allstate 3/5  –  Liberty Mutual 3/5
  • Pricing: Allstate 2/5  –  Liberty Mutual 4/5

Allstate or Liberty Mutual

Which one of these car insurance companies is best? The final decision will be up to you because only you know your unique circumstances and needs. Both companies are highly reputable, have a long history of servicing customers and are financially strong.

Its also important to note that these are not the only 2 car insurance companies of comparable size and reputation.

Companies like Geico, State Farm and Nationwide offer very comparable coverage so always compare at least 5 or 6 car insurance companies before selecting a provider.

Use our FREE quote tool to compare auto insurance rates today!

Related posts:

  1. Liberty Mutual Car Insurance Review
  2. Allstate vs. Geico
  3. Allstate vs. Farmers Car Insurance
  4. Allstate vs. State Farm Insurance
  5. Allstate vs. Amica